Wednesday, January 07, 2009

Day in the Life of Trevor - Working Class Tory

Waiting at home for British Gas to come and fix a leaking boiler I received a Google alert about a wonderful story written in 2004 by long lost American Cousin called originally “Day in the Life of Joe Middle Class Republican”. The original was by a John Gray (from Cincinnati, Ohio July 2004). It had been updated following the Obama victory here. I’m sure my “cousin” won’t mind me reworking it to the UK in 2010.

"Trev is determined to have a good day despite it all. He's still disappointed that Labour did so well in the election, that Gordon Brown will be Prime Minister again, and Labour will have a big majority in the House of Commons. But Trev’s a strong, freedom-loving, independent kind of bloke, and he doesn't intend to let the Labour lemmings ruin his life.

Trev and some of his equally Conservative friends have talked about the beatings the Tories have taken in the last four elections. They can't agree on why it happened, but they do agree on one thing, their bedrock truth: Whatever's wrong, it's the fault of the government, the unions and the bloody Labour Party.

Trev thinks about these things soon after he wakes up in his home in the London Borough of Bexley. He showers and walks to the kitchen to get the kettle going. His shampoo bottle is properly labelled with every ingredient and the amount of its contents because some interfering liberal fought for his right to know what he was putting on his body and how much it contained.
The water he uses is clean and safe because, at one time, tree-hugging extremists fought for effectively enforced, minimum water quality standards.

While he waits for his cuppa, Trev takes his daily allergy and blood pressure medications. His medicine is safe and effective because, years ago, some big-government liberal stuck his nose where it didn't belong and got the government to oversee the production of pharmaceuticals. Trev pays £8.54 per month for all his prescriptions thanks to the NHS, because 50 or more years ago, lazy union members helped make sure that a Labour Government was elected which introduced a National Health Service. All the actual medical treatment he has received over the years from his local doctor and in hospital have all been free.

Trev cooks up some bacon and eggs (both of which are safe because of Government food regulations and inspections), then turns on the radio in time to hear a right-wing talk show host rail against "government entitlements." "Bloody right," thinks Trev, "only wusses think the government owes them something ... bunch of Labour slackers."

Trev gets dressed, goes outside and takes a deep breath. The air is clean because environmentalist wackos 30 years ago got all worked up about industries polluting the atmosphere.

He gets in his Jeep and drives to work in the Isle of Dogs on a government-funded, government-maintained and government-patrolled highway. His vehicle is among the safest in the world because some fuzzy-thinking, "Kumbaya"-singing Labour weenies fought for car safety standards. Trev pulls into his office building's parking lot, made affordable for him and his company by tax breaks.

Trev starts his workday. He enjoys paid holidays, a 35 hour working week, overtime and a decent pension because lazy union loafers fought and died for enforceable working standards. Thanks to the Union if Trev is injured on the job, or God forbid, loses his job, he'll get Company and state sick pay, industrial injury compensation, redundancy payments and unemployment benefit as well as help with his mortgage-- all because some Frenchified socialist didn't think people should starve or lose their homes because of a temporary problem.

At lunch, Trev and some work friends drive to a local government-inspected restaurant while listening to Talk Radio. As they wait for their food, they talk about how tired they are of picking up the tab for "lowlifes who'd rather get a government handout than work," and their friends in "government". -- Which reminds Trev that he needs to send off his student loan payment. That money sure came in handy when Trev attended his state subsidised technical college.

After work, Trev goes home, checks his e-mail and surfs his favourite conservative Web sites for awhile. The Internet is readily accessible to Trev because some British-hating liberals convinced Parliament that giant communications companies shouldn't be given quicker Web access than ordinary citizens.

Trev plans to visit his parents this evening, they live out in Bow near Vicki Park. He drives again on the subsidised roads and soon pulls into the driveway of his parents place. His parents couldn’t get a mortgage from a bank to buy their home. They were only able to get one from their local council. And wouldn't you know it -- the house didn't have inside toilets or central heating until some pinko activists got together and demanded improvements and government grants for the area.

Trev, as always, is glad to see his parents, who are now retired. They live on the State pension and a decent company pension, all because some nosy Labourites made sure they could take care of themselves so Trev wouldn't have to.

As Trev drives home from his parents' house, he listens to a radio talk show. The host is talking about a new book that claims Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal in America actually prolonged the Great Depression, even though serious historians who agree with that premise are nearly non-existent. The host goes on, reminding listeners that conservatives are great and socialists are evil. He doesn't mention that it was conservatives who fought like wildcats against every protection and benefit Trev has enjoyed that day. As he pulls into his driveway in Bexley, Trev thinks to himself, "You're bloody right! We don't need any more big-government losers taking over our lives! Why can't everyone be a self-made man like me? People should take care of themselves without government help, just like I have."

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

Subsidised with what? Tax payers money!...its not Government money - they took it off Trev to start with. I pay a lot more tax than the state subsidises me...infact I am subsidising a load of other people. Your contribution is less than mine old chap

John Gray said...

Hi Anon
I hope you feel very proud of yourself for paying more out in tax than you think you receive. Well done, long will it continue! You probably need to pay some more (and will do if the Government gets its way) it will make you feel even better!

BTW - Do you work for your living or did you inherit your dosh?

Anonymous said...

I cant understand when you are very good at putting across an arguement and usually talk commonsense, that you fall to the depths of some of the gutter press by making what is a personal attack. Have a go at Tory policies, but this guy has a right to his views. You quite rightly tell us that our forebears faught hard for democracy - that fact that someone has the choice for who he wishes to vote for would be celebrated in some countries ruin by dictators.

Anonymous said...

Another Anonymous, by the way. Must be one of those days.

But this is laughable. This is probably the smuggest statement of a political view I've seen in year - that everything good in the world is down to people just like me. But now the nausea has passed, let's take a stroll through some of the lighlights...

"The water he uses is clean and safe because, at one time, tree-hugging extremists fought for effectively enforced, minimum water quality standards."

Rubbish. It was clean and safe to a reasonable degree before there were minimum standards, because moderate municipal types in the 19th century wanted to give a good service. No tree-hugging. Water managers kept it safe because they didn't want to get sued. In fact, the biggest danger to water quality in this country in recent times was public ownership - the end of which has seen a fall in nationwide hosepipe bans (some areas suffer because of changing climate), and a significant increase in quality because evil capitalists saw fit to invest.

"His medicine is safe and effective because, years ago, some big-government liberal stuck his nose where it didn't belong and got the government to oversee the production of pharmaceuticals."

We don't actually have 'big-government liberals' in this country. But the main reason that medicine is safe and effective is because drug companies want to sell it, and because they'd get sued under the common law if they didn't. All medicine control does is seek to reduce transaction costs of this enterprise - where it sometimes succeeds, sometimes fails.

"Trev pays £8.54 per month for all his prescriptions thanks to the NHS, because 50 or more years ago, lazy union members helped make sure that a Labour Government was elected which introduced a National Health Service."

... on a model which couldn't be afforded and had to introduce prescription charges, incidentally. But it was good that a party went to the 1945 election with the manifesto commitment that "The health services of the country will be made available to all citizens. Everyone will contribute to the cost, and no one will be denied the attention, the treatment or the appliances he requires because he cannot afford them." Oh, sorry, that was the Tory manifesto of 1945. Labour did manage the implementation - pretty badly, as it turned out.

"Trev cooks up some bacon and eggs (both of which are safe because of Government food regulations and inspections),"

I assume this means that all farmers, butchers and grocers practising before the 20th century were selling poisons. Actually, no. Just as with drugs, all we've done is replace one regulatory regime designed to minimise risks with another - sometimes better, sometimes not. But while most meals don't result in food poisoning, some still do - just as was ever thus.

"... then turns on the radio in time to hear a right-wing talk show host rail against "government entitlements.""

We don't have many railing right-wing talk show hosts in this country, you know. Different regulatory regime - set up by Conservative Governments, along with the freedoms for basically all non-public broadcast media.

"Trev gets dressed, goes outside and takes a deep breath. The air is clean because environmentalist wackos 30 years ago got all worked up about industries polluting the atmosphere."

Clean Air Act 1956? That'll be a Tory Government.

"He gets in his Jeep and drives to work in the Isle of Dogs on a government-funded, government-maintained and government-patrolled highway."

Indeed, and as a Tory, it's actually unlikely he's against them. If anything, Tories like government-funded roads. And there's no contradiction, because most Tories (especially those, like Trev, who aren't particularly engaged with politics except as a voter) aren't against government. This touches on the failure of this whole post - that Tories aren't like Republicans. The "freedom-loving" bit earlier sums this up - outside of blogging, most Tories aren't libertarians.

"His vehicle is among the safest in the world because some fuzzy-thinking, "Kumbaya"-singing Labour weenies fought for car safety standards."

The big change in car safety standards happened when Labour weenies weren't in power - during the 1980s and 1990s. But it was mainly an international thing, and cars are now as safe as they are mainly because the industry itself innovated when they realised it was a selling point.

"Trev pulls into his office building's parking lot, made affordable for him and his company by tax breaks."

What tax breaks? There aren't any tax breaks in this country for parking lots. Some local authorities are threatening to tax the use of them, as a matter of fact. And that's leaving aside the view that a tax break "makes something affordable" - that assumes Government owns all income, and we should be grateful if it allows us to keep some. I don't think you believe that, do you?

"Trev starts his workday. He enjoys paid holidays, a 35 hour working week, overtime and a decent pension because lazy union loafers fought and died for enforceable working standards."

Yes, and the industries with the best pay and benefits (technology, creative, business services) have little or no union involvement at all. And Trev might also reflect on how, 30 years ago, the union might have stopped him earning a living, because they were probably the biggest block on workplace progress going. Trev probably thanks Thatch every day for freeing him from the self-appointed bullies of the union movement.

"Thanks to the Union if Trev is injured on the job, or God forbid, loses his job, he'll get Company and state sick pay, industrial injury compensation, redundancy payments and unemployment benefit as well as help with his mortgage-- all because some Frenchified socialist didn't think people should starve or lose their homes because of a temporary problem."

Well, in fairness, the main features of the welfare state existed long before Frenchified socialists got into power. Germanised liberals did most of the heavy lifting. And then conservatives expanded it greatly. Oh, and I haven't mentioned that most of the key Factory Acts were legislated by Tory Governments.

"... Which reminds Trev that he needs to send off his student loan payment. That money sure came in handy when Trev attended his state subsidised technical college."

But wasn't it better when you didn't have to pay at all? Oh that's right, it was a Labour Government that made fees what they are now. And which Government expanded HE more than any other? Oh that'd be the Major Government.

"The Internet is readily accessible to Trev because some British-hating liberals convinced Parliament that giant communications companies shouldn't be given quicker Web access than ordinary citizens."

Who were these liberals exactly? What law did they pass? If anything, if it weren't for the privatisation of BT and the liberalisation of the cable industry, this country would've missed out on the internet age. But the internet itself, aside from being based on eeevil US military technology, developed fairly much outside of law and government.

"His parents couldn’t get a mortgage from a bank to buy their home. They were only able to get one from their local council."

And then Thatch forced the local council to give them the right to buy it. Labour opposed it, and opposed the liberalisation of mortgage lending, but luckily they weren't in power, and so his parents have owned their own home for decades.

"And wouldn't you know it -- the house didn't have inside toilets or central heating until some pinko activists got together and demanded improvements and government grants for the area."

Yes, and the elimination of housing without inside toilets and central heating finally happened in the late 1990s - when the council housing sector was at its smallest.

"They live on the State pension and a decent company pension, all because some nosy Labaourites made sure they could take care of themselves so Trev wouldn't have to."

State pension - liberals got there first. Company pensions - most of which have been disappearing since Labour were in charge.

"As Trev drives home from his parents' house, he listens to a radio talk show. The host is talking about a new book that claims Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal in America actually prolonged the Great Depression, even though serious historians who agree with that premise are nearly non-existent."

Well, I don't know so much about serious historians, but plenty of extremely serious economists (Nobel Prize-winning ones) do think that.

"The host goes on, reminding listeners that conservatives are great and socialists are evil."

... and is reminded of broadcasting regulations. This one's particularly funny, as the opposite sentiment seems to motivate this entire post.

"He doesn't mention that it was conservatives who fought like wildcats against every protection and benefit Trev has enjoyed that day."

Except car safety, publicly funded healthcare, good water, clean air, good working standards, buyable housing, etc., etc.

And no, it's not that I'm saying that everything good was down to people other than socialists. It's just that, being a grown-up, I prefer to give credit where it's due.

Pathetic.

Jackart said...

Agree with the previous anon. This really is the biggest load of smug, ignorant drivel I've read on a blog since I gave up reading Terry Kelly.

Anonymous said...

Utter drivel.

As a parody of a Tory. it could be quite funny, apart from the fact that it isn't! It's a load of smug rubbish and Labour self-backslapping. You guys can't avoid spin even in your own blogs!

Typical Labour - taking credit for inherited achievements, and then fiddling & pointing fingers while the house burns down. You've been taking a few pointers from Gordon Brown and his 'economic miracle', mate...

Anonymous said...

Great work of fiction. In your dreams, sunshine :)

ian said...

To the various anons, I think Trev might be a fictional character, but on a serious note the sentiment of the article is that everything we hold dear has been won throughout history by struggle against people like the Tories and their Capitalist backers.Its a shame that many working class Tories and the middle class the aspire to dont realise that.

A very happy socialist New Year to Tories everywhere!!

ian said...

John.

Your blog must be good if Tory anons are spending so much time attacking your views.

Keep it up

Ian

John Gray said...

Hi Anon
"I cant understand when you are very good at putting across an arguement and usually talk commonsense...."

Sorry, I should have made it clear that Trev is a figment of my imagination (I had to find a British version of “Joe”) and any resemblance to persons living or dead is purely coincidental. Trev was indeed never the Mayor of a saff London Borough.

John Gray said...

Hi Another Anonymous
Well done for your response. Complete and utter nonsense of course! But well done anyway. There is a future in UNISON united left if only you knew it!

I am now rolling my selves up...

Water safety - I don’t think that many people were sued in the 19th century? Not that many “no-win, no-fee” solicitors about maybe? It’s interesting that in the Capital of the “Land of the Free” the well known state run pinko organisation known as the US Army Corps of Engineers runs the drinking water supply for the City not private companies. I wonder why?

Drug safety – come off it anon – the drug industry is being sued left right and centre. The profit motive is too strong. If it wasn’t for government control and regulation the drug industry would go amok. Why wait to be harmed before you do anything?

NHS – well, in the USA no one is in theory is denied treatment. It may mean selling your house or being hawked around various hospitals until you find one willing to treat you for free mind

Food safety – Yes anon, yes, some “farmers, butchers and grocers practising before the 20th century were selling poisons” of course they will – just like in the recent China baby milk scandal. You make money out of adulation, you fool yourself you are not doing any harm. That’s why you need effective government intervention.

Right wing Radio bigots? So you will never get anyone in the UK whinging about spongers on the dole? Or asking mini cab firms not to send Asian cabbies to pick up their daughters?

Clean air? Come on anon – that measure was built upon the shoulders of socialist minded giants who had fought for decent air quality for decades.

Car safety – the big motor companies were deliberately, repeat deliberately selling cars that they were knew were unsafe. Who cares if your car gets wreaked easily – after all this means you can always sell another one!

Tax breaks for company car parks – of course companies get tax relief when building offices which have car parks. Many don’t charge their employees for parking while those who compute via public transport have to pay their fares out of taxed income.

Trade union benefits – trade union members are paid far more than non union members (even excluding non pay benefits). Too much flying in Ryan Air has addled your brains comrade (it's completely understandable). It was unions behind improvements in Liberal governments. I think most factory acts were enacted in the 19th century. I am very grateful that the Tories voted to stop child labour in coal mines. Well done.

Student loans – Hang on the Tories started it all off with loans instead of maintenance grants. I think there are now far more students than during Major?

Internet access – I’ll give you this one to a point. I’m sure that the media companies would have cherry picked even more if they could have got away with it without effective regulation.
Housing – his parents are being evicted for mortgage arrears next week. They have now worked out that with opportunity cost, maintenance, interest and capital repayments they should have remained tenants (not really).

Grants - It may have been finished by the 1990’s but this campaigning has been going on for decades often in the face of obstructive Tory opposition. It encourages too may working class to stay in the area.

Pensions – funny that the executives of the top FT 100 keep their final salary schemes while they take them away from their workers?

Nobel winning economists? Like “do nothing” Osborne?

Now, I must admit, credit where credit due. Some Tories are alright and do some good for society but as I think has been proved in the recent economic debacle they cannot be trusted and we must let the grownups remain in charge.

John Gray said...

Hi Jackart

Does this mean I can put you down as weak Labour possible?

Hi Troy
I appreciate that the concept is rather high brow and maybe you didn’t quite get it. Don’t worry I’m going to look after you and your mates and make sure that we have a special hardback “Labourbird Politics for Morons” to help you guys out. Hope this is helpful?

Hi Ian
Happy Socialist New Year to you as well!

John Gray said...

Hi Ian
I agree and we need to think why the unions are not seen as that important by many working and middle class employees. There again, I’ve not yet met a worker yet who wouldn’t have benefited from being a member of the union.

Anonymous said...

John your article has been demolished

John B said...

By whom? Cos it certainly hasn't been demolished by any of the eejit commenters above...

Jackart said...

Ha Ha! Alas, John, No. You can't. Nice try though.

Charlie Marks said...

Congratulations on the feather-ruffling, John! Keep up the good work.