Friday, December 07, 2007

Letter about Tory political infidelities


My apologies for not posting this link sooner - an excellent post from Labour & Capital about the investment fund managers Fidelity, who unlike all other major British managers are significant financial contributors to the Conservative Party. Over £320,000 in the last three years.

Tom P (the author) and his wife, have an ISA investment account with them. He has written this letter asking why they are donating money to the Tories, are they planning future contributions and do they disclose these donations when they bid for business in Conservative controlled Council pension fund authorities?

I would argue that they should disclose this fact before bidding for business for any local authority not just ones with a Tory majority? A Council pension scheme panel will probably still have Tory members present even if they do not control the authority. I am sure that they will not want to be put in a potentially compromising position. Also, vulnerable without any such declaration of interest by Fidelity would be any Council officers present or their professional advisors if they themselves are Conservative Party members or supporters? Actually I’m sure this information will be gratefully received in the Labour heartlands.

Anyone who has an investment or personal pension plan with Fidelity should consider sending the same letter. Also check to see if your insurance or pension scheme employ Fidelity as their fund managers. If so, you should consider writing to your plan administrators or trustees asking them about the wisdom of employing such partisan managers.

Tom and wife point out that if Fidelity continues to give money to the Tories they will move their savings. However, usual health warnings about taking appropriate advice before you actually change any such investments apply.

A letter to Fidelity

The letter below has gone in the post this morning. My wife and I have been with Fidelity for about 6 years now. We have an ISA we set up to help pay off our mortgage, so we were intending to stick with them for the long run. We are therefore both really p***ed off that we may have to go through the hassle of changing fund manager because the one we chose prioritises making partisan political donations over the concerns of its customers. I hope they reply saying they are going to halt the donations. But if they won't stop doing it we feel we have no option but to move our savings elsewhere.


Fidelity International,
Oakhill House,
130 Tonbridge Road,
Hildenborough,
Tonbridge,
Kent TN11 9DZ

My account Number: XXX My Adviser: XXXI

I was concerned to learn from the Electoral Commission website that Fidelity International has donated £95,000 to the Conservative Party so far during 2007. I am not a Conservative Party supporter, but I do not believe that a fund management business like Fidelity should make donations to any political party.

As you are no doubt aware most institutional investors will vote against resolutions at companies’ AGMs where authority is sought to make party political donations. Indeed party political donations are rare amongst listed companies these days.

It is therefore somewhat surprising to see an institutional investor make such donations itself.

As a long-standing Fidelity customer I am very concerned by these donations. I would therefore be grateful if you could answer the follow questions.

1. What is the rationale for making donations to the Conservative Party?

2. Does Fidelity intend to make similar party political donations in future?

3. Does Fidelity disclose these donations when this is a potential conflict of interest (ie when presenting to Conservative-controlled local authority pension funds)?

I also wish to make clear that if Fidelity does intend to continue making partisan political donations I am likely to move my family’s savings to another fund manager.

Yours sincerely

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

The fact is Labour have messed up and messed up bad, so looking at who else mucks up makes nothing better. We should be able to write about things like this from a clean point of view sadly Labour is not clean and thats the problem.

Praguetory said...

You're explaining why donors choose the illegal anonymous route. In sympathy, I'll be in touch with Fidelity to try to set up some funds.

Anonymous said...

So what about David Abrahams who gave 660K to Labour and then amazingly enough the objections from the Highways agency to his planning application for a business park were withdrawn - what a sleazy can of worms! Even Mr.Bean had to admit labour has broken law - oh I bet he wishes he hadn't bottled it now over the election! The Iron Chancellor, Ho Ho, Ho! The economy is really on the slide now and all his mis-management is going to comeback to haunt you!

John Gray said...

Hi Anon

“The fact is Labour have messed up...”

I agree. Labour has messed up and heads have/will roll.

John Gray said...

Hi Praguetory

The issue with Fidelity is that almost uniquely they are giving the Tories money out of company profits. Apart from serious governance issues this also means that UNISON members in say Greenwich and Haringey, whose pension funds employ Fidelity, are indirectly contributing to the Conservative Party. If the directors want to give money directly out of their own pocket then they should do so. But I suppose this is why they prefer to do it via their company?

BTW – I have just checked – I don’t think as a good modern Cameron Tory you would like the range offered by Fidelity – No Green funds!

John Gray said...

Hi Anon

“So what about David Abrahams.....”

I am probably being a little naïve but the one good thing about that whole sorry tale could be that we have effective regulation and transparency of political donations in the future. How many investors (or pensioners or people with insurance policies) in Fidelity realise they give money directly to the tories?

...I saw Brown on TV at Wednesday PMQT give Cameron a good verbal kicking. It was overdue, granted – but it looks very promising for the future.

Anonymous said...

Does Unison have an opt into the political levy or an opt out? It has an opt out ....I wonder why?

Anonymous said...

The economy has hit the buffers...what has Mr.Bean kept in reserve during this time of plenty?

John Gray said...

Hi Anon

“Does Unison have an opt into the political levy....”

Actually UNISON has an “opt in” – you have the choice of ticking the box or not (and you can always opt out)

John Gray said...

Hi Anon

“The economy has hit the buffers....”

Well, maybe after 40 consecutive quarters of economic growth the economy needs to slow them a little?

Tom Powdrill said...

Hi John

Got a reply from Fidelity today. Will post up tomorrow.

Basically they don't answer my questions, which is strange since I'm customer, so I'm going to have to write back.

John Gray said...

Hi Tom

I’ll look forward to that, Interesting – remind them about their claims to “provide high-quality customer service”..... our commitment always to act in the best interests of our clients.... Fidelity is well aware of the importance of customer support and satisfaction, and we do as much as we can to look after our customer's interests. ......about the ways in which we maintain the highest standards of service”

– The usual drivel I suppose. Not meant in the slightest?

Anonymous said...

Maybe it is in the interest of their customers that the Conservatives get in? The economy is going down the toilet and Mr.Bean didn't exactly do a great deal for the pensions industry - not to mention the enormous defecit he has run up...the economy. Brown deserves everything he is going to get in the next 18 months - he should have had more spine and gone to the polls - what a mis judgement!

Tom Powdrill said...

"Maybe it is in the interest of their customers that the Conservatives get in?"

In that case maybe they should disclose to their customers that they are making these donations.

John Gray said...

Hi Comrade Anon

“Maybe it is in the interest of their customers that....”

I agree with tom and would also note how noble the Fidelity management are in giving up their hard earned profits for the greater good of their customers.

Nothing to do at all of course with the expectation that a tory government would reduce their (already marginal) income and corporation taxes. No, they are just high minded honest citizens who have no alternative goal but a belief in the greater good....and fat untaxed dividends?

Yeah.